Skip to main content
Top10Grid
Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas — Sports Top 10 List

Alex Morgan / Wikipedia

Sports Event

Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

Penalty shootouts are football's purest form of theatre — and the FIFA World Cup has produced some of the most nerve-shredding moments in sports history. From the very first shootout in 1982 to Messi's ice-cold kick in 2022, these 12 shootouts account for 8 eliminations decided by a single missed spot kick. Baggio's miss in 1994, Beckham's red card in 1998, Schumacher's unpunished assault in 1982 — this is the list that defines World Cup drama, heartbreak, and redemption.

2026607 views

Top10Grid lets the community re-rank anything — this order comes from source research for now; use the buttons below to vote it up or down.

Current Rankings

  1. 0

    #1 Argentina vs France — 2022 World Cup Final — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Emiliano Martínez saved Kingsley Coman's penalty and Aurelien Tchouameni blazed over as Argentina won 4-2 on penalties after the most dramatic final in the history of football. Kylian Mbappé scored a hat-trick in 97 seconds to force extra time from 3-1 down, then equalized again at 3-3 to drag the shootout into existence. Lionel Messi scored his penalty ice-cold to end a 36-year wait and seal his World Cup. More than 1.5 billion people watched worldwide — the most-watched sporting event of the decade.

  2. 0

    #2 Brazil vs Italy — 1994 World Cup Final — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    The first World Cup Final to be decided by penalties and still the most watched in history, with over 1 billion viewers in 1994. Roberto Baggio's skied miss gave Brazil a 3-2 shootout win after 120 goalless minutes at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena. Baggio placed his hands on his head and his image became the most reproduced sporting photograph of the decade — a portrait of unbearable public failure that defined an era of Italian football.

  3. 0

    #3 England vs West Germany — 1990 World Cup Semifinal — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Stuart Pearce and Chris Waddle missed as England lost their third consecutive major tournament shootout. Gazza cried. A nation collectively experienced sporting heartbreak on a scale not seen before. The shootout has haunted English football for 35 years, inspiring rule changes, specialist coaches, and an entire industry of psychological research into penalty taking.

  4. 0

    #4 Argentina vs Netherlands — 2022 World Cup Quarterfinal — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Emiliano Martínez saved two penalties as Argentina won 4-3 after an extraordinary match that ended 2-2 and featured Messi's most provocative performance ever. His deliberate taunt of the Dutch bench after scoring, combined with Martínez's notorious mind-game goal celebrations, generated days of media controversy. Wout Weghorst had equalized in the 83rd and 90+11th minutes to force extra time, making Argentina's shootout win feel like a miracle.

  5. 0

    #5 Spain vs Paraguay — 2010 World Cup Quarterfinal — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Spain's 2010 quarterfinal shootout win over Paraguay in Johannesburg completed their journey to a first World Cup title. David Villa scored from the spot as Spain won 5-3 on penalties after Oscar Cardozo blazed over for Paraguay. The psychological significance went beyond the result: Spain were proving they could win the ugly way after decades of beautiful-football-but-no-silverware trauma, resolving a complex national identity crisis that had gripped Spanish football since 1964.

  6. 0

    #6 France vs West Germany — 1982 World Cup Semifinal — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    The first ever World Cup penalty shootout produced one of the tournament's greatest dramas. France led 3-1 in extra time before West Germany mounted an extraordinary comeback to force penalties. Harald Schumacher's brutal foul on Patrick Battiston — which knocked him unconscious and was unpunished — remains one of the most controversial moments in World Cup history. West Germany won 5-4 on penalties in a match that changed football's relationship with justice and fair play.

  7. 0

    #7 Morocco vs Spain — 2022 World Cup Round of 16 — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Goalkeeper Yassine Bounou (Bono) saved penalties from Pablo Sarabia and Carlos Soler as Morocco eliminated Spain 3-0 on penalties after 120 goalless minutes in Doha. The result shocked European football — Spain, runners-up in 2010, were beaten without conceding or scoring a single goal across 120 minutes. Morocco became the first African nation to reach the World Cup semi-finals, triggering celebrations across the Arab world and a night of euphoria in Casablanca seen by an estimated 25 million people.

  8. 0

    #8 Italy vs France — 2006 World Cup Final — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Italy won 5-3 on penalties in Berlin after Zidane's infamous headbutt on Marco Materazzi sent the France captain off in the 110th minute of his final professional game. David Trezeguet was Italy's villain, hitting the crossbar, as Fabio Grosso slotted the winning kick. Italy won the World Cup despite having been dominated for most of the 90 minutes — a match history will always remember for the headbutt rather than the penalty shootout or the scoreline.

  9. 0

    #9 England vs Argentina — 1998 World Cup Round of 16 — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    David Beckham's red card for flicking his heel at Diego Simeone defined English football for years, as ten-man England were eliminated 4-3 on penalties despite Michael Owen's wonder goal making it 2-2. Sol Campbell's disallowed header and Beckham's sending-off remain two of the most controversial moments in World Cup history. David Batty and Paul Ince missed as Argentina progressed.

  10. 0

    #10 Germany vs Argentina — 2006 World Cup Quarterfinal — Top 10 World Cup Penalty Shootout Dramas

    Jens Lehmann used a secret notepad hidden in his sock listing the tendency of each Argentine penalty taker — and saved two penalties from Ayala and Cambiasso to send Germany through 4-2. The revelation of the "cheat sheet" transformed penalty preparation across world football, as every goalkeeper coach subsequently adopted detailed pre-match shootout dossiers.

World Cup Penalty Shootouts — Your Questions Answered

When was the first FIFA World Cup penalty shootout? The first was the 1982 semi-final between West Germany and France in Seville — the very match ranked #6 on this list — and it immediately cemented the shootout as the tournament's most theatrical tiebreaker.

Which country has the best World Cup shootout record? Germany (including West Germany) has historically dominated, winning five of six World Cup shootouts through 2022. England, by contrast, lost their first five before defeating Colombia in 2018.

Who saved the most penalties at a single World Cup? Emiliano Martínez saved three penalties across two shootouts at the 2022 FIFA World Cup — against the Netherlands in the quarter-final and against France in the final — the best single-tournament return by a goalkeeper in the competition's history.

Image credits
  • Argentina vs France — 2022 World Cup Final: Lionel Messi / Wikipedia
  • Brazil vs Italy — 1994 World Cup Final: NielsF, modified by: Jackys. / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
  • England vs West Germany — 1990 World Cup Semifinal: Penalty shoot-out (association football) / Wikipedia
  • Argentina vs Netherlands — 2022 World Cup Quarterfinal: Wikimedia Commons
  • Spain vs Paraguay — 2010 World Cup Quarterfinal: Christen Press / Wikipedia
  • France vs West Germany — 1982 World Cup Semifinal: Penalty shoot-out (association football) / Wikipedia
  • Morocco vs Spain — 2022 World Cup Round of 16: Sam Kerr / Wikipedia
  • Italy vs France — 2006 World Cup Final: Photo by David Ruddell Cropped and retouched by Danyele / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
  • England vs Argentina — 1998 World Cup Round of 16: Lionel Messi / Wikipedia
  • Germany vs Argentina — 2006 World Cup Quarterfinal: Moazzam Brohi from Brooklyn, USA / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Related Videos

Argentina v France: Full Penalty Shoot-out | 2022 #FIFAWorldCup Final

FIFA28.5M views

Who has the best penalty kick? ⚽️🥅

JianHao Tan24.0M views

Lionel Scaloni's Reaction to Lautaro Martinez's Penalty

FIFA12.2M views

Dramatic Penalty Shootout #1

GrdArena12.0M views

Dramatic Penalty Shootout #1

GrdArena12.0M views

Rank it your way

Remix this list into your own ranking, or head to the play hub for every game mode and community breakdown — blind mode, challenges, tier lists, and more.

Play this list →