

The sequels that betrayed their predecessors, squandered beloved franchises, and proved that lightning rarely strikes twice in gaming. These follow-ups took everything fans loved about the original and systematically dismantled it in the name of trends, greed, or sheer incompetence.
Top 10 lists on this topic
Curated by our gaming editors. Tracks both critical reception and community vote — updated as new releases shift the conversation.
Create a free account or sign in to join the discussion.
Sign in to join the conversation
BioWare Montreal's 2017 follow-up to one of gaming's greatest trilogies launched with horrifying facial animations, lifeless open worlds, and writing that made Commander Shepard's adventures feel like Shakespeare by comparison. It killed the franchise for five years and shuttered the studio.

Rare's 2008 Xbox 360 sequel took a beloved 3D platformer franchise and turned it into a vehicle-building game nobody asked for. The opening literally mocked fans for wanting a traditional sequel, and the series has been dormant for nearly two decades as a result.
Capcom's 2003 sequel stripped away everything that made the original a stylish action classic. Dante went from a wisecracking demon hunter to a mute bore, the combat was dumbed down to hold-trigger-to-win gunplay, and the level design was so empty it felt procedurally generated before that was a thing.
Maxis' always-online reboot shrunk city plots to a fraction of SimCity 4's size, forced multiplayer integration into a single-player franchise, and launched with servers that collapsed immediately. The backlash was so severe that EA killed the SimCity brand and pivoted to Cities: Skylines competitor status.
343 Industries' 2015 sequel marketed a Master Chief vs. Locke rivalry that lasted approximately two cutscenes. Its campaign was the worst in series history, it shipped without split-screen co-op for the first time ever, and the REQ Pack loot boxes tainted its otherwise solid multiplayer.
Robomodo's 2015 disaster required a day-one patch larger than the game itself and launched with physics so broken that skaters clipped through floors and launched into orbit. It scored a 32 on Metacritic and effectively killed one of the most beloved franchises of the PS1 era.
Microsoft's 2019 sequel spent five years promising revolutionary cloud-powered destruction that never materialized. The final product was a generic open-world collectathon that felt like a 2010-era game, wasting Terry Crews' infectious charisma on a hollow shell of a game.
EA Los Angeles' 2010 finale to the Tiberium saga removed base building from a real-time strategy franchise built on base building. It required an always-online connection for single-player, capped unit counts, and delivered a campaign so insultingly short that fans pretend it does not exist.
Sonic Team's 2006 reboot shipped with loading screens lasting up to a minute, controls that fought the player at every turn, and a plot where Sonic kissed a human princess. It is the definitive example of how far Sega let their mascot fall and the benchmark for franchise disgrace.

Visceral Games' 2013 sequel traded the isolated horror of the original for co-op action and microtransactions at EA's insistence. The shift from survival horror to cover-based shooter alienated the fanbase so completely that EA shelved the franchise and eventually shut down Visceral entirely.
The most-voted lists across every category — curated weekly. Join the early readers.
No spam. One email per week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Explore more Gaming rankings on Top10Grid
Cast your vote above to unlock the real distribution
Tap the arrows on any item to vote
Top 10 YouTube Channels to Watch for Gaming in 2026
111 views · @admin

Top 10 Most Anticipated Video Games of 2025-2026
62 views · @admin

Top 10 Greatest Chess Players of All Time
54 views · @admin

Top 10 Best RPG Games of All Time
53 views · @admin

Top 10 Mobile Games That Are Actually Worth Your Time
45 views · @admin

Top 10 Best-Selling Video Games of All Time
45 views · @admin
Because you're viewing Gaming

Steam Top Sellers — Week 18, 2026 (Live Rankings)
346 views · 1 votes

Top 10 Steam — Top Sellers — Apr 20–Apr 26, 2026
118 views · 1 votes
Top 10 YouTube Channels to Watch for Gaming in 2026
111 views · 0 votes
Top 10 Most Watched Esports Events of 2025
96 views · 0 votes

Top 10 Video Games of 2025
72 views · 0 votes

Top 10 Best Board Games of All Time
69 views · 0 votes
BioWare Montreal's 2017 follow-up to one of gaming's greatest trilogies launched with horrifying facial animations, lifeless open worlds, and writing that made Commander Shepard's adventures feel like Shakespeare by comparison. It killed the franchise for five years and shuttered the studio.

Rare's 2008 Xbox 360 sequel took a beloved 3D platformer franchise and turned it into a vehicle-building game nobody asked for. The opening literally mocked fans for wanting a traditional sequel, and the series has been dormant for nearly two decades as a result.
Capcom's 2003 sequel stripped away everything that made the original a stylish action classic. Dante went from a wisecracking demon hunter to a mute bore, the combat was dumbed down to hold-trigger-to-win gunplay, and the level design was so empty it felt procedurally generated before that was a thing.
Maxis' always-online reboot shrunk city plots to a fraction of SimCity 4's size, forced multiplayer integration into a single-player franchise, and launched with servers that collapsed immediately. The backlash was so severe that EA killed the SimCity brand and pivoted to Cities: Skylines competitor status.
343 Industries' 2015 sequel marketed a Master Chief vs. Locke rivalry that lasted approximately two cutscenes. Its campaign was the worst in series history, it shipped without split-screen co-op for the first time ever, and the REQ Pack loot boxes tainted its otherwise solid multiplayer.
Robomodo's 2015 disaster required a day-one patch larger than the game itself and launched with physics so broken that skaters clipped through floors and launched into orbit. It scored a 32 on Metacritic and effectively killed one of the most beloved franchises of the PS1 era.
Microsoft's 2019 sequel spent five years promising revolutionary cloud-powered destruction that never materialized. The final product was a generic open-world collectathon that felt like a 2010-era game, wasting Terry Crews' infectious charisma on a hollow shell of a game.
EA Los Angeles' 2010 finale to the Tiberium saga removed base building from a real-time strategy franchise built on base building. It required an always-online connection for single-player, capped unit counts, and delivered a campaign so insultingly short that fans pretend it does not exist.
Sonic Team's 2006 reboot shipped with loading screens lasting up to a minute, controls that fought the player at every turn, and a plot where Sonic kissed a human princess. It is the definitive example of how far Sega let their mascot fall and the benchmark for franchise disgrace.

Visceral Games' 2013 sequel traded the isolated horror of the original for co-op action and microtransactions at EA's insistence. The shift from survival horror to cover-based shooter alienated the fanbase so completely that EA shelved the franchise and eventually shut down Visceral entirely.
If you liked this, you might love these

Top 10 Worst Game Endings
10 items

Top 10 Worst Video Game Launches
10 items

Top 10 Worst Gaming Trends
10 items

Top 10 Worst Gaming Community Behaviors
10 items

Top 10 Worst Gaming Peripherals
10 items

Top 10 Worst Microtransaction Practices in Gaming
10 items