rt tv netflix May 4–May 10, 2026
Most Popular TV Shows on Netflix (May 2026)
The week of May 4–May 10, 2026, saw Netflix users cling to comfort food and true-crime dread. The streaming chart from Rotten Tomatoes TV & Netflix, which combines Tomatometer scores with audience signals, reveals that subscribers aren't just chasing prestige—they're sampling risky new series alongside proven hits. Topping the list is *Beef* (92% Tomatometer), a 2023 holdover whose raw anxiety still resonates. But the real story is lower down: the 100% Tomatometer documentary *Trust Me: The False Prophet* proves audiences will reward flawless critical consensus, while the eerie 83% score for the barely released *If Wishes Could Kill* signals a breakout horror-thriller. This data matters because Rotten Tomatoes aggregates critic and audience feedback, giving a fuller picture than simple view counts. The rankings are drawn from a weekly snapshot of Rotten Tomatoes' Netflix-specific chart, capturing what people actively choose to watch.
736 views
1
?
Top10Grid Editorial
Curated by our entertainment editors. Built from critical consensus and community vote.
- 1. Beef — *Beef*, the 2023 A24 comedy-drama, grabbed the top spot with a 92% Tomatometer and a 74% Audience Score, proving that road-rage existentialism still draws crowds on Netflix years after its debut.
- 2. Unchosen — *Unchosen*, a 2025 drama-thriller, sits at number 2 with a 73% Tomatometer but only 43% from audiences—critics liked its tense premise more than viewers did.
- 3. Stranger Things: Tales From '85 — *Stranger Things: Tales From '85*, the animated fantasy-horror spin-off, lands at 3 with a weak 61% Tomatometer, suggesting franchise name recognition outweighed critical praise this week.
- 4. Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen — *Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen*, a 2025 comedy-thriller, scores an 87% Tomatometer—a sharp contrast to its 61% Audience Score, indicating critics embraced its dark humor over general audiences.
- 5. Trust Me: The False Prophet — *Trust Me: The False Prophet*, a 2025 documentary, achieved a perfect 100% Tomatometer and nearly matching 95% Audience Score, making it the week's most universally acclaimed entry.
- 6. Running Point — *Running Point*, a 2025 drama-sports series, holds at 6 with solid 84% Tomatometer and 78% Audience Score, a reliable performer without breakout hype.
- 7. If Wishes Could Kill — *If Wishes Could Kill*, a 2026 horror-thriller, debuts at 7 with an 83% Tomatometer, signaling strong early traction for a genre entry before the audience data has fully settled.
- 8. Should I Marry a Murderer? — *Should I Marry a Murderer?*, a 2026 true-crime documentary, appears at 8 without reported Tomatometer or Audience scores, yet still charts—true-crime loyalists don't need critical validation.
- 9. Big Mistakes — *Big Mistakes*, a 2026 comedy series, earns a 78% Tomatometer and 77% Audience Score at position 9, a competent but unspectacular performance in a weak comedy week.
- 10. Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole — *Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole*, a 2025 crime-drama-mystery, closes the top 10 with a strong 91% Tomatometer but only 76% Audience Score, appealing to Nesbo fans more than casual viewers.
Current Rankings
- 1#1
Beef
1
*Beef*, the 2023 A24 comedy-drama, grabbed the top spot with a 92% Tomatometer and a 74% Audience Score, proving that road-rage existentialism still draws crowds on Netflix years after its debut.
- 0#2
*Unchosen*, a 2025 drama-thriller, sits at number 2 with a 73% Tomatometer but only 43% from audiences—critics liked its tense premise more than viewers did.
- 0
*Stranger Things: Tales From '85*, the animated fantasy-horror spin-off, lands at 3 with a weak 61% Tomatometer, suggesting franchise name recognition outweighed critical praise this week.
- 0
*Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen*, a 2025 comedy-thriller, scores an 87% Tomatometer—a sharp contrast to its 61% Audience Score, indicating critics embraced its dark humor over general audiences.
- 0
*Trust Me: The False Prophet*, a 2025 documentary, achieved a perfect 100% Tomatometer and nearly matching 95% Audience Score, making it the week's most universally acclaimed entry.
- 0
*Running Point*, a 2025 drama-sports series, holds at 6 with solid 84% Tomatometer and 78% Audience Score, a reliable performer without breakout hype.
- 0
*If Wishes Could Kill*, a 2026 horror-thriller, debuts at 7 with an 83% Tomatometer, signaling strong early traction for a genre entry before the audience data has fully settled.
- 0
*Should I Marry a Murderer?*, a 2026 true-crime documentary, appears at 8 without reported Tomatometer or Audience scores, yet still charts—true-crime loyalists don't need critical validation.
- 0
*Big Mistakes*, a 2026 comedy series, earns a 78% Tomatometer and 77% Audience Score at position 9, a competent but unspectacular performance in a weak comedy week.
- 0
*Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole*, a 2025 crime-drama-mystery, closes the top 10 with a strong 91% Tomatometer but only 76% Audience Score, appealing to Nesbo fans more than casual viewers.
Vote items up or down — rankings update instantly
Get the weekly entertainment rundown
The most-voted lists across every category — curated weekly. Join the early readers.
- The most-voted lists across every category
- Exclusive early-access to new categories
- Reader picks vs editorial picks compared
No spam. One email per week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Readers Also Ranked
More Lists Like This
Top 10 Best Streaming Shows of 2026 to Binge Right Now
- #1Adolescence (2025)
- #2Andor: Season 2 (2025)
- #3The Pitt: Season 2 (2026)
Top 10 Summer Blockbuster Movies of 2026 You Need to See
- #1Project Hail Mary (2026)
- #2Toy Story 5 (2026)
- #3The Super Mario Galaxy Movie (2026)
Top 10 Celebrity Feuds That Broke the Internet in 2026
- #1Blake Lively vs. Justin Baldoni
- #2Elon Musk vs. Ashley St. Clair
- #3Taylor Swift vs. Kanye West
Top 10 Streaming Shows to Watch in June 2026
- #1The Bear — Season 5 (Final Season)
- #2House of the Dragon — Season 3
- #3Cape Fear
Trend Analysis
Drama and thriller dominate this week's top 10, accounting for six of the ten entries. Comedy makes a weaker showing, with only *Beef* (1) and *Big Mistakes* (9) carrying strong humor credentials. The biggest surprise is *Stranger Things: Tales From '85* at number 3, a spin-off that scores only 61% Tomatometer—suggesting franchise fatigue even as curiosity drives viewing. True crime is represented by the incomplete data of *Should I Marry a Murderer?*, which lacks both a Tomatometer and Audience Score, yet still charts—indicating genre loyalty trumps quality signals. The list reveals a public appetite for dark, interrogative content: documentaries, moral puzzles, and psychological thrillers. The outlier is *Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole* at 10, a 91% Tomatometer crime drama that likely appealed to the literary fan base but didn't crack the mainstream. Expect more true-crime documentaries to edge into the top five as the year progresses.
Discussion
Create a free account or sign in to join the discussion.
Sign in to join the conversation
More Entertainment Rankings
You might also want to rank…
Top 10 Netflix Shows to Watch in 2026
Top 10 Best Movies of All Time
Top 10 Google Trends — Daily (GB) — May 5, 2026
Top 10 Streaming Shows to Watch in June 2026Explore more Entertainment rankings on Top10Grid
People Also Explore
Because you're viewing Entertainment
Top 10 Netflix Shows to Watch in 2026
12,004 views · 0 votes
Top 10 Best Movies of All Time
941 views · 0 votes
Top 10 Google Trends — Daily (GB) — May 5, 2026
719 views · 1 votes
Top 10 Streaming Shows to Watch in June 2026
438 views · 0 votes
Top 10 Bad Bunny Albums Ranked
436 views · 0 votes
Top 10 Celebrity Feuds That Broke the Internet in 2026
319 views · 0 votes