Most Popular TV Shows on Paramount+ (May 2026)

**Off Campus** lands at number two with a 96% critic score and 89% audience score, making it the most universally liked show in the top ten this week.

**Widow's Bay** surprises at number three with a 97% Tomatometer — the highest critic score on the entire list — though the 92% audience score shows broad appeal.

**The Boys** holds steady at number four with 93% critic approval, but the 74% audience score hints that viewers may be tiring of the show's relentless cynicism.

**Nemesis** is the week's most polarizing entry: critics give it 90%, but a 42% audience score signals a show that simply does not click with mainstream viewers.

**Devil May Cry** boasts a stellar 98% Tomatometer, the second-highest critical score in the top ten, yet the 72% audience score reveals that style alone doesn't guarantee viewer love.

**Lord of the Flies** earns a solid 92% from critics but a weak 57% audience rating, underscoring how faithful literary adaptations often alienate casual watchers.

**Beef** returns with 93% Tomatometer and 74% audience score, a drama that continues to hold its ground among streaming originals despite season-long controversies.

**Dutton Ranch** scores 83% critics and 78% audience, a rare instance of near-total alignment between professional and viewer opinions in this week's list.

**Good Omens** rounds out the top ten with 78% Tomatometer and 74% audience, still charming enough to crack the list but trailing far behind newer releases.