Unchosen

Unchosen is this week's clearest critic-audience split: a 62% Tomatometer against a 42% Audience Score, a 20-point gap that's hard to explain away as noise. Critics responded to the tense premise; general viewers largely didn't, which tracks with a 2025 drama-thriller that leans harder into ambiguity than most streaming audiences reward. It trails Beef by 36 points with critics — a real comparison, since both scores are on this same chart — but the audience gap is the more interesting story: only about four in ten viewers who tried it said they liked it.