Does The Secret of Chimneys deserve the #1 spot on “Top Classic Books — Detective and mystery”?
Best Rank
#1
top 3 in 1 list
Avg Position
#3
across 2 lists
Community
#1 Pick
avg #3 overall
Ranked #1 on "Top Classic Books — Detective and mystery". Cast your vote to back or challenge this spot.
Be the first to vote on this ranking.
Most Argued About
“Most Popular Project Gutenberg Downloads — September 2026 (Top 10 Classic Books)”
Ranks as high as #1 on some lists — but only #5 here. Fans are divided.
See the debate →The Internet's Surprise Pick
“Top Classic Books — Detective and mystery”
Climbed to #1 — a narrowly contested win.
See the full ranking →
Crime and Punishment
2 shared lists

Pride and Prejudice
1 shared list

Moby-Dick
1 shared list
Romeo and Juliet
1 shared list
The Mysteries of Udolpho
1 shared list
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
1 shared list
A Room with a View
1 shared list
The Odyssey: Rendered Into English Prose for the Use of Those Who Cannot Read the Original
1 shared list