WWE 2K20

2K's October 2019 wrestling game launched with character models that looked like melting wax figures, gameplay glitches that sent wrestlers flying into the stratosphere, and a bug that crashed the game every time the real-world date hit January 1, 2020. Compared to #2 on this list, E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, its 45% user score on Metacritic actually outperforms WWE 2K20's 33%, making it the worst-rated wrestling game on the platform.