Jell-O Pudding Pops

Frozen pudding on a stick — Jell-O figured out how to make pudding portable and cold, and kids of the '80s and '90s lost their minds. The chocolate-vanilla swirl was the crown jewel. Kraft discontinued the original in the 2000s, licensed the name to Popsicle brand, and the replacement was universally panned as a pale imitation. The original had a creamy, slightly icy texture that no frozen treat has replicated since. It occupied a unique niche between ice cream and pudding that nobody else has claimed.