My Favorite Murder

My Favorite Murder commands the most devoted fanbase in true crime comedy, with each episode drawing 8 million loyal "Murderinos" in 2025. Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark's irreverent approach to dark material, paired with candid mental health discussions, has built a community that spends 34% more on merchandise than the average podcast audience. This show pioneered the comedy-true-crime genre and still leads it, with a listener retention rate 22% higher than #6 Diary of a CEO's audience.