Pepperoni

Pepperoni's dominance as the #1 topping is undeniable, driving 36% of all US pizza orders. Each slice averages 10-12 pepperoni pieces, delivering consistent flavor with every bite. The perfect balance of spice, salt, and those satisfying grease cups forms when baked at 475°F, creating crispy edges that elevate the entire pie. This outperforms #2 Mushrooms by 6 percentage points in popularity, while the rendered oils produce a texture that fresh toppings cannot replicate, ensuring a superior crunch.