The Boys

The Boys, the anti-superhero satire from 2019, landed at No. 2 with 11,988 votes—the highest vote tally on the entire list—cementing its status as the most-voted show but failing to dethrone a dark-horse horror hit. This total is 4.5 times larger than the 2,663 votes gathered by FROM, yet it still fell short of the top spot. With a 95% Rotten Tomatoes critic score and 8.7/10 IMDb rating, it outperforms the average superhero series by 22% in critical reception. Its explosive Season 4 finale drove a 30% spike in weekly viewership, yet even that momentum could not overcome FROM's viral surge.