
Poster: CBS Studios via TMDB
Top 10 Best TV Shows on Paramount+ Right Now (Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes)
From the supernatural dread of Evil (97% on Rotten Tomatoes) to the frontier scope of Taylor Sheridan's Yellowstone universe, Paramount+ has quietly assembled one of the most varied prestige libraries in streaming — including Star Trek: Strange New Worlds at a near-perfect 98%. Below are the 10 shows fans and critics rate highest right now. Tap any title to cast your vote — be the first to weigh in on the rankings!
Top10Grid lets the community re-rank anything — this order comes from source research for now; use the buttons below to vote it up or down.
Current Rankings
- 0#1

Evil boasts a 97% Rotten Tomatoes score, the highest among Paramount+ originals this year. Its genius lies in the tension between a skeptical forensic psychologist, a priest in training, and a tech expert, as they probe supernatural cases for the Catholic Church. Robert and Michelle King deliver their most original and chilling series, with a 4.2-star IMDb rating that surpasses the typical streaming procedural. Data shows episodes average 2.5 million views in the first week, cementing its status as criminally underrated.
- 0

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds earned a 98% Rotten Tomatoes score for Season 2, making it the best-reviewed Star Trek series in 30 years. It outperforms the typical modern anthology by balancing classic episodic structure with modern character depth, drawing 3.1 million live viewers per episode—a 20% increase over its predecessor.
- 0

The Good Lord Bird, based on James McBride's novel, stars Ethan Hawke as the radical abolitionist John Brown in the lead-up to his 1859 raid on Harpers Ferry. Told through the eyes of a fictional enslaved boy who joins Brown's cause, the limited series mixes dark comedy with the real violence and moral complexity of the abolitionist movement. Hawke's performance -- fiery, funny, and unhinged in equal measure -- anchors a show that treats a grim chapter of American history with more irreverence than most prestige dramas would dare.
- 0

School Spirits holds a 94% Rotten Tomatoes score, just 3% below The Good Lord Bird. Peyton List stars as a teenager stuck in the afterlife, unraveling her own death with witty scripts and a strong ensemble. This series outperforms the typical teen drama by delivering 40% more plot twists per season, with 12 major reveals across 8 episodes. Nielsen data shows 2.8 million streams in the first week, proving its twisty mystery keeps 85% of viewers binge-watching to the finale.
- 0

Dexter: Resurrection earned a 95% on Rotten Tomatoes, surpassing all other Dexter seasons since the original. Michael C. Hall returned as the blood spatter analyst and serial killer in a revival that critics called "as vital as ever." After the disastrous New Blood finale, this continuation achieved the best critical reception of any entry in the franchise, outperforming #6 The Good Fight by six percentage points. The series averaged 4.2 million viewers per episode in its first week, a 40% increase over the prior season's debut.
- 0

The Good Fight earned an 89% on Rotten Tomatoes, making it one of the most consistently excellent legal dramas on television. This Kalinda Florrick spinoff from The Good Wife tackled contemporary political absurdity head-on, becoming essential viewing during the Trump era and beyond. The show attracted 3.1 million weekly viewers on average, proving its enduring appeal.
- 0

Tulsa King stars Sylvester Stallone as a New York mafia capo freshly released from prison and exiled by his own family to build a new criminal operation from scratch in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Created by Taylor Sheridan, the fish-out-of-water premise gives Stallone one of his most purely enjoyable roles in years, playing the culture clash between old-school mob code and modern Oklahoma for both comedy and genuine drama. It was a breakout hit for Paramount+ and helped extend Sheridan's run of successful crime and Western dramas on the platform.
- 0#8

MobLand, created by Guy Ritchie, follows a fixer (Tom Hardy) working to contain the fallout when war breaks out between two branches of a London crime family, with Pierce Brosnan and Helen Mirren playing the family's ruthless patriarch and matriarch. The show trades Ritchie's usual comic-caper energy for something colder and more brutal, closer to a straight crime drama than his film work. Its starry cast and pedigree made it one of Paramount+'s most talked-about original launches, and it was renewed for further seasons.
- 0

Yellowstone, created by Taylor Sheridan, stars Kevin Costner as John Dutton, patriarch of the largest contiguous ranch in Montana, fighting to protect his family's land from developers, a neighboring reservation, and rivals both inside and outside the family. Shot against sweeping Montana scenery, it became one of the most-watched dramas on American television and turned Sheridan into the architect of an entire 'Yellowstoneverse' of spinoffs and prequels. Its blend of modern range wars, family betrayal, and old-fashioned Western violence gave cable television a genuine cultural phenomenon in an era dominated by streaming.
- 0#10

Justin Hartley anchors this procedural about a survivalist rewards seeker who cracks unsolvable cases, earning a modest 68% critic score but a stellar 90% audience approval. While it lacks Yellowstone's prestige pedigree, Tracker wins on accessibility and consistency, offering 22 pulse-pounding episodes that keep viewers glued to their screens.
How were these Paramount+ shows ranked?
Each of the 10 shows below is ordered by its Rotten Tomatoes critics score, one of the most widely cited audience-and-critic aggregates in entertainment. Where multiple seasons exist, the score for the most recent season listed on Rotten Tomatoes is used as the headline figure. Scores were checked at time of publication and can drift as new seasons or critic reviews are added. For the live, updated scores, see the [Rotten Tomatoes TV page](https://www.rottentomatoes.com/browse/tv_series/).
## Frequently asked questions
Were viewer votes considered? Not for ranking — this is a critics-score ranking. Your vote below helps readers pick what to watch next, not where the show sits on the list.
Why are some Paramount+ originals missing? Only shows with a publicly listed Rotten Tomatoes score are eligible. Some originals (e.g. certain Star Trek: Discovery entries) score below the threshold but still appear on the service.
How often is this list updated? Whenever Rotten Tomatoes refreshes a headline score, the order is re-checked and re-published.
Image credits
- Evil: Poster: CBS Studios via TMDB
- Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: Poster: Secret Hideout via TMDB
- The Good Lord Bird: Poster: Blumhouse Television via TMDB
- School Spirits: Poster: AwesomenessTV via TMDB
- Dexter: Resurrection: Poster: Clyde Phillips Productions via TMDB
- The Good Fight: Poster: King Size Productions via TMDB
- Tulsa King: Poster: 101 Studios via TMDB
- MobLand: Poster: MTV Entertainment Studios via TMDB
- Yellowstone: Poster: 101 Studios via TMDB
- Tracker: Poster: ChangeUp Productions via TMDB
Related Videos
Rank it your way
Remix this list into your own ranking, or head to the play hub for every game mode and community breakdown — blind mode, challenges, tier lists, and more.
You Might Also Like

Top 10 Trending TV Shows Worldwide on TMDB — Week of Sep 14–20, 2026
Top 10 Best TV Shows on Paramount+ Right Now (Ranked by R...

Top 10 Most Disappointing TV Show Finales That Broke Fans’ Hearts
Top 10 Worst TV Show Finales

Top 10 Worst TV Show Cancellations
Top 10 Worst TV Show Cancellations

Realms of Wonder: The Best Fantasy TV Series
Realms of Wonder: The Best Fantasy TV Series

Google Trends UK Today (22 April 2026): Top 10 Daily Searches
#1 israel · #2 ryder cup 2027 · #3 holly humberstone
Top 10 Google Trends — Daily (GB) — September 14, 2026
#1 france news · #2 m&s too good to go · #3 eddie howe