Poster: Production I.G via TMDB
Top 10 MyAnimeList — Most Popular Anime — September 2026
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood continues its relentless grip on anime perfection, holding a staggering 9.11 MAL score that no challenger has displaced. Attack on Titan and Death Note remain cultural pillars with combined member counts exceeding 8.7 million, proving that finished series maintain commanding fanbases years after their final episodes. This ranking measures community engagement through member counts—essentially how many users have added each anime to their lists—alongside critical reception via score. Readers should care because these numbers reveal which stories have achieved timeless resonance versus fleeting viral moments. September 2026 data shows shonen dominance persists, with six of ten spots held by action-oriented series, yet the quality gap is stark: Brotherhood's 9.11 dwarfs My Hero Academia's 7.82 at rank six. The numbers aren't just abstract metrics; they represent millions of deliberate choices by viewers selecting what deserves their time.
Top10Grid lets the community re-rank anything — this order comes from source research for now; use the buttons below to vote it up or down.
Current Rankings
- 0
Attack on Titan secures the top position with 4,393,830 members, making it the most-added finished anime on the platform—a testament to its brutal world-building and high-stakes narrative that earned an 8.57 score.
- 0
Death Note claims the second spot with 4,331,343 members despite being a psychological thriller rather than action shonen, proving that character-driven storytelling rivals spectacle with an impressive 8.62 score.
- 0
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood achieves the highest quality rating at 9.11 with 3,709,235 members, demonstrating that a tightly paced 64-episode story can rival series with double or triple its length.
- 0
One-Punch Man reaches rank four with 3,539,908 members across just 12 episodes, delivering one of the strongest member-per-episode ratios in the top ten and an 8.47 score that reflects its satirical brilliance.
- 0
Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba maintains its modern classic status with 3,477,770 members and an 8.40 score, showing that the 2019 series has solidified its place alongside decade-old giants.
- 0
My Hero Academia drops to rank six with 3,328,631 members and a 7.82 score, suggesting that while the series maintains strong viewership, critical reception lags behind its shonen predecessors.
- 0
Sword Art Online sits at rank seven with 3,317,457 members but carries the lowest score in the top ten at 7.23, revealing a significant gap between popularity and quality perception.
- 0
Hunter x Hunter claims rank eight with 3,214,762 members and an exceptional 9.03 score, proving that despite its sprawling 148-episode length, the series delivers consistent quality that approaches perfection.
- 0#9
Naruto fills rank nine with 3,137,808 members across 220 episodes and an 8.02 score, showing that the franchise's cultural impact doesn't translate to top-tier ratings compared to newer competitors.
- 0#10
Tokyo Ghoul closes the list with 3,074,503 members and a 7.79 score despite only 12 episodes, indicating that its dark atmosphere and concise narrative earned devoted fans despite limited content.
Image credits
- Attack on Titan: Poster: Production I.G via TMDB
- Death Note: Poster: Madhouse via TMDB
- Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood: Poster: BONES via TMDB
- One-Punch Man: Poster: Madhouse via TMDB
- Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba: Poster: ufotable via TMDB
- My Hero Academia: Poster: BONES via TMDB
- Sword Art Online: Poster: A-1 Pictures via TMDB
- Hunter x Hunter: Poster: Madhouse via TMDB
- Naruto: Poster: Pierrot via TMDB
- Tokyo Ghoul: Poster: Pierrot via TMDB
Trend Analysis
The September 2026 top anime list reveals a landscape dominated by action shonen, with every entry falling into battle-adventure territory—demonstrating the genre's unmatched global appeal. The data exposes a clear quality stratification: FMA:B and Hunter x Hunter's 9+ scores tower over entries like Sword Art Online (7.23) and Tokyo Ghoul (7.79), suggesting viewers increasingly differentiate between cultural phenomena and genuine artistic achievement. One-Punch Man's rank-four position despite only 12 episodes reveals that conciseness wins fans: it accumulated 3.5 million members faster per-episode than My Hero Academia's 13-episode run. The shonen-heavy composition—no slice-of-life, romance, or psychological thriller breaking through—suggests the anime community skews heavily toward action spectacle. Expect seasonal releases to challenge these entrenched titles, but finished series will likely retain their positions as evergreen recommendations.
Rank it your way
Remix this list into your own ranking, or head to the play hub for every game mode and community breakdown — blind mode, challenges, tier lists, and more.
You Might Also Like
Top 10 Anime Series for Newcomers
Top 10 Anime Series for Newcomers
Top 10 MyAnimeList — Most Popular Anime — May 2026
Top 10 MyAnimeList — Most Popular Anime — May 2026
Top 10 YouTube — Trending Videos (US) — September 1, 2026
#1 Jarahn x SHLD - Yu Les (Audio) feat. Nene Morus & Rich Antony · #2 Lanterns Episode 4 Trailer: Sinestro, Guy Gardner Green Lantern & Things You Missed! · #3 The HOLE is back...
Realms of Wonder: The Best Fantasy TV Series
#1 Saving Hope · #2 Adventure Time · #3 The Venture Bros.
Top 10 Comedy Clubs in London 2026
#1 The Comedy Store · #2 Soho Theatre · #3 Angel Comedy at The Bill Murray
Top 10 Most Influential Documentaries of All Time
#1 Bowling for Columbine · #2 An Inconvenient Truth · #3 Blackfish